420hc vs 154cm vs s30v. Some companies, groups, people, etc.

CPM S30V vs 154CM Sep 24, 2014 · Yes there is a difference. CPM 3V Steel vs. M390 is new to the knife world so it hasn't had time to gain general acceptance yet with the production companies. 50%. Apr 21, 2022 · It's not hard to beat the Leatherman 420HC on edge retention. Jul 12, 2023 · S30V, a premium-grade steel with high Chromium and Vanadium content, offers good toughness, wear resistance, and superior corrosion resistance. 420HC is a stainless steel that provides excellent rust resistance, ease of re-sharpening and medium edge retention. Edge Retention: Because of the mix of high carbon and chromium, S30V is a very good at keeping its edge. On the other hand, the 420HC is ideal for people who need something for frequent sharpening needs on a budget that will fulfill their outdoor tasks. May 9, 2023 · 420HC vs. Because of this, it is an exceptionally good choice for blades that are used in heavier cutting applications, or by just plain old Joe Blow who would rather not spend too much Sep 22, 2023 · Read More 420HC steel vs 154CM | Which steel is better? Knife Steel. The s30v is much harder, so it cuts better even against stronger materials. I have an easy solution for you to make the right decision. Jan 27, 2008 · For the "test" I used my Benchmade 426BK (154CM, plain edge) and my trusty Spyderco 83mm Manix (S30V, plain edge). I've found S30V to hold an edge longer, but 420HC is easier (read quicker) to sharpen. S30V, on the other hand, was developed by steelmaker Crucible Industries in coordination with leading knifemakers specifically for use in high-end pocket Sep 29, 2022 · 420HC vs S30V Toughness. 4% vanadium. His response led to the creation of S30v Oct 15, 2023 · While they may look similar on the surface, the two have several key differences. S30V 420 HC lies on the affordable and low range price scale and the other hand S30V is a premium quality steel with a pricey tag. 440C. It’s much better at retaining its sharp edge too. 45% compared to the X50CrMoV15 steel’s 0. CPM 154 on Buck 110 Bass Pro shows better results then CPM S30V on Buck 110 Cabela's Alaskan Guide. I know 154cm/cpm154 are good and that s30v is "better" (I don't know specs off the top of my head, but Metal Complex ranked them about the same for usability. Developed specifically for knives, S30V contains vanadium, enhancing its wear resistance and ability to retain a sharp edge. Dec 19, 2021 · In terms of toughness, they both offer good toughness but are moderately low compared to the likes of Nitro-V steel and 420HC steel. S30V is a premium stainless steel developed by Crucible Industries. 420HC small vs 440C big), big wins. Both were touched up on my Sharpmaker at 40 degrees prior to cutting. Mar 20, 2015 · Because if it's one of the sheepsfoot ones with a hollow grind, I'd say you ht the jackpot. Buck does a solid job with 420… but if you want a May 28, 2024 · 14C28N VS Steel. So, let’s look at whether D2 or 420HC is better. 420HC steel is a budget-friendly option that offers decent corrosion resistance but has relatively low hardness. S30V is a high vanadium stainless steel with even higher edge retention. Feb 24, 2021 · I’d stay away from 420 base steel altogether. 때문에 굳이 따지자면 스테인리스강 기준 쓸만한 보급형으로는 420hc [43]와 440a가 있으며 보급형~중상급은 440c급, 중상급~상급은 154cm이나 vg-10급, 그 이상의 프리미엄급은 s30v급 이상의 분말강 정도로 간주하는 사람들이 많다. 05% more carbon and 1% more vanadium, S30V provides slightly better edge retention. It has balancing properties that are Mar 6, 2023 · In partnership with Crucible Industries, a steel producer based in New York, Chris Reeve developed the S35VN and S30V steels using a specialized technique known as Crucible Particle Metal (CPM) technology. On the other hand, S30V is hard steel and delivers decent toughness. High corrosion Apr 7, 2006 · Steels with a lot of carbides resist this. 420HC Offers close edge retention, close toughness and the same level of corrosion resistance compared to the 440C Steel. VG-10 takes a much finer edge then 154CM, and holds it a hair longer. I believe that S30V probably takes and holds a keener edge longer, but 154CM is great steel. What it is: 420HC is a relatively soft, cost-effective stainless steel. CPM S30V has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 59-61, providing a solid balance between toughness and edge retention. Jan 9, 2007 · All are very similiar in my experience, S30V is a little tougher than 154cm, and will hold an edge slightly longer than both, but the trade off is it will also be slightly more difficult to sharpen, between 154cm and VG-10 almost no difference really, VG-10 might hold an edge like 2% longer, but the blade grind/edge will make way more of a difference, so in actual use, between the three there May 14, 2009 · from what i have heard cpm 154 is similar to s30v. The vast majority merely parrot data from Apr 15, 2023 · It can be a tough decision until you don’t see the result of these steel performances. Jul 12, 2023 · S35VN vs. 1075 some vs 1095 more), more resists abrasion better. S35vn Compared; 154cm Steel vs. 84″ drop point blade with a Serrated Edge, comes with glass-filled Nylon with TPV overmold handle and a reinforced sheath (the sheath has a little practical sharpener in it), in addition of this a pointed buttcap that is made of stainless steel in the end of the blade that Oct 15, 2023 · While 420HC and 154cm are corrosion-resistant, 154CM offers better overall toughness and durability. S30V Stainless Steel. Nov 30, 2007 · I have knives in both 154CM and S30V and I prefer 154CM. There are no real downsides to S30V, however, it does not excel in some areas as some more specialty knife steels do. Knives with S30V and S35VN blades have proven popular in the medium and premium-priced knife markets. It most certainly gives you a better edge retention than normal cutlery or stainless steels. 420HC knives will withstand high-impact applications compared to 420HC Knives. It's a step or two down from the comparison class here. But it matches the S30V corrosion resistance, while the VG10 is also somewhat easier to sharpen. I love 154CM, because it's easier to sharpen than S30V, and the hollow grind on the 154CM Griptilians cuts way better than the saber ground S30V Grips. some have said its a bit better some disagree. Oct 27, 2009 · The progression was : 440c , 154CM , CPM 154 , S35VN , S30V . CPM-154 has superior performance characteristics with respect to both 154CM and ATS-34, but 154CM and ATS-34 are both very high quality blade steels. Feb 25, 2024 · S30V Steel vs 420HC S30V steel, known for its remarkable balance of hardness, toughness, and corrosion resistance, stands as a premium option in the knife-making community. sharpening ability. 420HC offers better toughness and corrosion resistance than 440C steel. S30V and CPM154 can keep semi-sharp for a long time. AEB-L and 14C28N also have moderate edge retention though of course much lower than vanadium-alloyed powder metallurgy steels like S30V or M390. 14C28N is considered a budget-friendly stainless steel, while S35VN commands a premium price as a high-performance steel. Much like S30V, 154CM is a very well rounded steel. Jul 21, 2023 · 420HC. Cedric & Ada Gear and Outdoors. 2% molybdenum. Which of the two you choose will ultimately rely on your tastes, intended use, and financial situation. 420HC is easier to sharpen because it is far less abrasion-resistant than 440C or S30V, making it easier to machine for Buck. Advantages: Easy to sharpen, extremely corrosion-resistant (the most corrosion-resistant of the 400-series stainless steels). AEB-L May 10, 2021 · LC200N and BD1N have much lower wear resistance than S30V and the CATRA test is an edge wear test. Take S30V Steel. Just like 154CM, S30V was created by Crucible Industries and was a breakthrough improvement in 2001. This company had already made great strides in developing high-quality steels, when they asked Chris Reeve why he wasn’t using any of their capable steels for his knife making. I think 154 had better toughness and s30v more had corrosion resistance iirc). Short answer : 420 hc will be easier to sharpen but won't hold the edge near as long. Substituting niobium carbides for some of the vanadium carbides makes CPM S35VN about 15-20% tougher than CPM S30V without any loss of wear resistance. While S30V generally offers better edge retention and corrosion resistance, 154CM provides greater toughness and is easier to sharpen. It’s actually not as hard, and not as tough, as CPM S30V. It developed the steel Mar 30, 2023 · Key Differences Between 154CM and S30V. This a well-known beast in the knife market, if you’re looking for a Fixed knife LMF II is a great choice, it has a 4. And this article Discoverthedinosaurs. It also offers optimal performance. When looking at Sandvik 14C28N vs CPM S35VN blade steels, we see differences that make each better suited for particular knife applications. They wanted to make something that was simple to heat-treat, well-balanced to suit a wide range of applications, and better than everything else at the price point. CPM S30V steel is one of the most corrosion and wear-resistant pocket knife steels available. With that said S35vn is plenty tough for a smaller blades and folders that are used mostly for cutting and not for conditions requiring a lot of toughness. S30V. Conclusion. ) The marketing associated with each new steel that comes out makes it hard not to get jaded. Jul 13, 2023 · 154CM vs CPM S35VN – Complete Comparison Hardness. i would have to imagine that cpm 154 is a bit better on edge holding. Jul 30, 2008 · I tested all four my Bucks 110 - CPM S30V, CPM 154, BG-42 and 420HC. S35VN and S45VN are easier to sharpen Mar 21, 2016 · A better comparison would be Japanese ATS 34 vs VG10 And 154cm versus N690co Since then 420hc and 8cr13mov but don't hold an edge as long as S35vn, S30v Jun 16, 2003 · S30V has roughly twice the carbon of 420HC and a significant amount of vanadium, which 420HC lacks. 022"). Handle Materials Unlike D2 and CPM-D2, there isn’t a difference between S30V and CPM-S30V. I've carried a benchmade griptilian in 154CM for a few years and it's never underperformed. Don’t confuse CPM 154 with 154 CM steel, CPM154 is a developed version of the 154CM Steel, benefiting from the CPM process of Crucible, many costume knife maker finds their ease in using the CPM 154 Steel thanks to it balance properties, which attracted my intention. S30V should be a step up from the comparison class with AR-RPM9. Mar 21, 2011 · 420HC vs S30V. And with each steel getting more and more popular, it can be hard to choose which one is better. What is 420HC Steel? 420HC steel is a type of stainless steel made with high carbon content for increased hardness. Both 420 stainless steel and S30V steel are highly corrosion-resistant. Also S30V is a better hard use steel imo. Multi-tool blades are way behind the times compared to the EDC knife market. I'd certainly hope it holds a better edge! Sep 28, 2022 · S30V is also easy to sharpen compared to other premium steels. Most S30V blades cost between $130 and $250, while the average D2 blade costs between $40 and $80. S30V and CPM-S30V are the same steel, but with different names. On like for like blades S30V, 3V and even A2 is going to outlast and stay sharp longer 420HC by a large margin. Many can't seem to decide between 420HC and S30V. The Sebenza 21. One reason is the 420HC blade, which is tough and damn easy to maintain. Moving from Benchmade's 154CM to their S30V and Spyderco's S30V, I've had hit or miss edge-retention. This steel can endure considerable use without chipping or breaking. Compared to Sandvik 12C27, 420HC steel is less wear-resistant and may require more frequent sharpening. In any case, I'm fine with either, and there's lots of knives in the $150 space that have s30v or 154 versions. 45% carbon. This is far more diffcult than the one of 154CM, that's common sense. however I have not used AUS 10A. Joined Oct 17, 2015 Messages 11,449. 154CM exhibits a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 58-61, which strikes a fine balance between toughness and edge retention. When carbides are the same size (e. Feb 9, 2010 · S30V is superior to VG-10 in every aspect except cost. 45% carbon; 14% chromium; 2% molybdenum; 4% vanadium; Edge Retention: S30V offers excellent edge retention. And if execution is average or below you’ll be disappointed. Soft steels like 420HC tend to offer great toughness. Note that some tests show similar edge retention between the 3, close to ELMAX. 154CM is a tougher, more flexible, and more corrosion-resistant stainless steel than S30V. 14C28N is a good steel for tools like scalpels, but S30V is considered a premium steel. From my experience, 154CM holds a "working edge" very well. In-Depth Look at 154CM. Toughness Jul 21, 2023 · CPM Magnacut vs Non-Stainless Steels. Definitely not a premium steel. Jun 23, 2002 · And it will not be any harder to sharpen than 154CM. D2: What’s The Difference? 1095 Steel Vs S30v at Outdoor Discovery 1095 steel and S30V are both types of carbon steel, but there are some key differences. Here is the short answer: D2 is harder and has better edge retention, but 420HC has a lot better corrosion resistance. He's 100% correct, not pretentious. I'm particularily interested in its edge holding verse 154cm and 420HC. 5 days ago · It all started with S30V. I believe the reports that CPM154 is better than 154CM. Jun 18, 2023 · I have used s35vn quite a bit at work and for outdoor activities. stainless thread? The difference between CPM154/S30V and 52100/1095? The carbon steels rust! They tend to be harder so they keep the initial sharp edge longer than the CPM stainless, but they just wear duller and duller. CPM 4V and CPM 3V are both high toughness tool steels that sacrifice some corrosion resistance for increased toughness. Buck TiAlN coating is best in the industry, most durable and also nice looking. It also sharpened a lot easier. I've also heard (or read that) 420HC is more corrosion resistant, but I don't have any S30V blades that seem very eager to corrode away either. I only have one blade in S30V, the Military, but it is probably the best steel I've used to date. Is 154CM the same as CPM154? However, S30V will be harder to sharpen and more expensive compared to 14C28N. Jun 8, 2014 · Buck 154CM vs Benchmade 154CM vs spyderco 154CM vs kershaw/ZT 154CM Buck S30V vs Benchmade S30V vs spyderco S30V vs kershaw/ZT S30V I know buck does the best 420hc with the bos heat treat and edge 2x so it would makes sense to say that buck has the best 154CM and S30V right? but I'm wounding who truly has the best But I don't have the money to Oct 15, 1998 · As to Buck's 420HC performing as well as S30VIn the test Buck posted they clearly note the edge profile of the blade is what gave their knife the advantage vs the thicker blade it was tested against. It is best known for its ability to be good at just about anything. S30V is a steel that is overall good steel. Any test showing comparable performance between S30V and LC200N is either poorly controlled (different edge geometry, sharpening is different, testing is inconsistent, etc) or the dominant edge dulling mechanism is not wear, such as edge deformation. Here is the composition of S30V: 1. Jan 7, 2007 · Also I got a CSAR-T with 154CM and tested it on some cardboard And In my test it held a finer edge a bit longer then S30V but it did Dull completely before S30V did. Dec 31, 2016 · 420HC can be sharpen on most any stone but doesn't hold an edge nearly as well as 154CM & S30V. S30V is a steel that is known for being a good all-around steel. S30V article to help you understand their properties, pricing, and more. S30v will be harder to sharpen but will hold the edge for much longer. It is also easier to machine and polish than CPM S30V. It has higher carbon content at 1. S30V and S35VN are nearly equally matched. Apr 2, 2005 · The other topic was: heat treatment of S30V. Who uses it: Great Eastern Cutlery, Kershaw, Schatt & Morgan. Edge-retention vs. Both steel types belong to the 400 series. Dec 24, 2023 · 9Cr18MoV vs 420HC. It's like A2 versus D2. I have no trouble sharpening 154CM. S30v is stainless steel that was created by American-based Crucible Industries in 2001, with knife blades in mind. Jul 5, 2023 · Read this 420HC vs. Pros. 73. This can be attributed to the good wear resistance of S30V brought about by the powder metallurgy process. We expect a reduction in toughness when compared with S35VN because of the increase in total carbide content. 440C VS 154CM Differences: Jun 9, 2020 · CPM-S30V/S35VN/S45VN - 7|5|6|5 - 341 TRC. Better at what ? general edge retention : s30v. My understanding is that the very first layer of carbides is just not properly where it should be: on Jul 12, 2023 · CPM S30V vs CPM S90V – Complete Comparison Hardness. If you want to make that a reality, I will buy your 154CM blade, trade you a 420 blade, some 420, whatever you want for that sweet sweet 154CM LOL Nov 17, 2015 · For many users the 420HC is a good choice. Apr 2, 2008 · It is a much more recent product than either 154CM or ATS-34 which, as noted, are nearly identical. It is an upgrade from 420HC but remains less expensive compared to S30V Steel, making it a suitable alternative to 14C28N. While 420HC is a stainless steel, 1095 is a carbon steel often used in traditional knives. creator-spring. 020" vs ~. Jul 14, 2023 · Edge retention: S30V > 420HC; Durability: S30V > 420HC; Ease of sharpening: 420HC > S30V; 420HC vs 1095. Both 9Cr18MoV and 420HC will resist corrosion and rusting in equal amounts. Mar 26, 2023 · You must have encountered 420HC and 400C stainless steel while looking for lower to mid-range knives. 154CM, D2, 440C all take more time and care to re-edge - and, as yet, i haven't persevered to get a razor's edge on one yet! I guess, longevity of edge retention and ease of re-edging considered, 420HC has been, in my humble opinion, better than many other metals - including 12C27. Yes, the s30v compares very well with 420hc when it comes to corrosion resistance, though 420hc is a little bit more rust-resistant. Dec 29, 2021 · What would really be a dream is to get a 154CM blade to replace these scissors with on the Wave, having three steels on my Leatherman That just tickles the nerd in me, man. 420HC is a softer steel and can be prone to wear and tear after heavy use. M4 Steel vs S30V | Who Wins the Battle? By Jinetcutter March 17, 2023 July 25, 2023. The 14c28n steel is basically an entry level steel used by Kershaw (Think Chive, Scallion, Leek) althought the knives do come in higher end steels. Apr 11, 2024 · Buck’s Vantage is one of the brand’s many blades that use 420HC See more 154CM steel knives S30V. 420HC steel is known for its ease of sharpening. 154CM is a good upgrade, but there are quite a few steels out there that are better for EDC. Says Buck: May 28, 2023 · S30V steel is more common; therefore, you will find more knives in S30V steel than in S35VN steel. Like how S30V is the predecessor to S35VN, 154CM is a modified version of 440C. I would go for the s30v. If you have any experience with these tool steels. If you are a newbie in knife sharpening, it is good steel to practice with. This post will cover everything you need about 420HC steel vs S35VN, including their composition, performance, and which is better for your needs. Compared to Sep 10, 2023 · S30V offers better edge retention and toughness compared to 154CM, while 154CM is generally easier to sharpen and has slightly better corrosion resistance. You can expect S30V to hold an edge similar to (not exact) to CTS-XHP. In this article we cover how to sharpen your multi tool and which sharpeners we recommend. I love my Titan and S30V, and CPM154 drop points, but I keep gravitating back to the traditional clip points. edge-retention. While 420HC is good stainless steel for the price, S30V has better materials, therefore, making it better steel. I’ve also used some other premium knife steels like s30v, cpm 154, 20cv and 3v. S30V contains 4% vanadium which facilitates substantial hard vanadium carbide formation, allowing it to reach hardnesses up to 64 HRC with optimal heat Nov 7, 2017 · (To be clear, S30V is just as great as ever as shown by these S30V steel knives. Jul 5, 2023 · D2 steel is more affordable than S30V, so knives fashioned from it are invariably cheaper. 420HC vs S30v Steel. D2 Steel Compared; 154CM vs VG10 Steel Compared Jan 28, 2008 · S30V takes some time to re-edge - but lasts quite well. Edge retention: 1095 > 420HC; Toughness . It's very stainless as well. Aug 22, 2020 · Buck Bos 420hc has much more toughness than S35vn. 420HC stainless steel is an advancement of the old 420 steel. Oct 15, 2023 · Difference Between 420HC Steel and S30V Steel Sharpness: First, let’s talk about sharpness. I've found Leatherman's implementation of 420HC to be fantastic. On par with VG-10. Overall I don't think the jump from 154CM to S30V is wort the cost of returning and buying a new knife. S45VN leads in edge retention (580), followed by S30V (254) and S35VN (190). Disadvantages: Relatively modest edge-holding. Due to its higher carbon content, it has a higher Rockwell hardness rating, making it more resistant to chipping, bending, and breaking. 154CM & S30V can be sharpened on a Lansky turn box just fine. However, being high-end steel, S30V knives are expensive. YMMV The sheepsfoot, hollow ground blade is a great knife and probably a very poor crowbar. You are viewing the article: 1095 Vs. 45% carbon, 14% chromium, 2% molybdenum, and 4% vanadium) and both are powdered steels. Comparing CPM Magnacut to non-stainless steels, such as CPM 4V, CPM 3V, CPM CruWear, and 420HC, reveals even more significant differences. non thread, or a carbon vs. S30V boasts superior hardness, edge retention, and corrosion resistance, making it a harder steel that delivers more bang for the buck. The Gerber Gator is available with a 154CM steel blade. If I need to cut down a lot of cardboard, I reach for my Buck 500 with 440C, and not another Buck with 420HC. If you’d like to see more knife-related blogs, just click here. Nov 1, 2019 · The main changes we expect from S45VN vs S35VN and S30V are an improvement in corrosion resistance due to the increase in Cr of about 1%. Know more with RangerExpert! In-Depth Look at S30V. Oct 2, 2023 · S30V was developed in 2001 by steelmaker Crucible Industries in coordination with leading knifemakers specifically for use in high-end pocket knives. Yet overall, it’s a tie between the 154cm and s30v. g. Some companies, groups, people, etc. 5%. And the first feature that we will talk about is its durability. Both 420HC and D2 are very common steels. Corrosion and wear resistance. Yes its cheaper, but to me the massive loss in performance makes 420HC a POOR choice. Honestly both are phenomenal are a plus from 420hc In-Depth Look at S30V. This steel is durable enough to withstand rigorous use without chipping or breaking. Whether it’s an S30V Elite Auto, this 440C Lochsa wanna-be, a 154CM 560, or something else; I find a clip point 110 in my pocket more than drop points and I have a nice selection of each to choose from. For a good comparison, you can expect 420HC to perform about like AUS8 as they are in a similar class. I would definitely go with the CPM154 rather than 420HC. They both are excellent but not of the same quality. All children of 440c. Crucible produces this American-made powder steel. If it is, go with D2. Sharpening 154CM and S30V blades is not as easy as your standard Swiss Army Knife or 420HC blade. They’re almost identical in composition (S30V contains 1. 154CM is an American-made stainless steel with very good corrosion resistance, edge retention, and toughness. com will help you answer the following questions about 1095 vs d2: 1095 cro van vs s30v damascus vs d2 1055 steel vs 1095 01 steel vs 1095 d2 steel 1095 steel vs Oct 19, 2021 · Rather than upgrade from D2 to M4 or S30V just drop the angle from 40 degrees to 30 degrees. Sometime last year I asked a similar question but it Apr 14, 2023 · The primary difference between S35VN and S30V is the improved wear resistance. 420HC offers better Toughness than S30V due to the decreased Rockwell hardness, it is thus less brittle than S30V steel. Oct 30, 2019 #1 So if X amount Jun 15, 2020 · The toughness is similar to steels with lower carbon content like 420HC but with higher potential hardness. Nov 14, 2023 · On the other hand, S30V offers great balance between hardness, corrosion resistance, and edge retention, making it a popular choice for everyday carry blades. Among the numerous steel options available to make a knife blade, 420HC and S30V stand out as two prominent contenders. In a head-to-head comparison between 154CM and S30V knife steels, both options offer advantages and disadvantages depending on the user’s needs. Jan 11, 2023 · The main difference between s30v vs. And some standard steels like 420hc, 1095 440a, 425m 9cr18mov and similar. Jan 29, 2024 · Final Thoughts on 14c28n vs s35vn. May 21, 2022 · The s30v in fact, is better in terms of edge retention but that’s traded off with difficult sharpening as compared to the 154cm. S30V is a powdered metallurgy stainless steel, specifically designed for high-performance knives. While 1095 provides better toughness and edge retention, it lacks corrosion resistance compared to 420HC. Thread starter Makael; Start date Oct 30, 2019; Makael Loving wife, kids and life. However, 420 and 420J2 are much less worthwhile and are better suited to non edged component duty. 14% chromium. 2K subscribers. It is budget steel that offers high Toughness and corrosion resistance. On the other hand, 440C shines in edge retention. Jun 27, 2018 · https://cedric-ada-store. S30V seems to be at it's best at 60 HRC for edge holding, but most production companies get it hardened lower than that at 58-59 HRC. Nov 10, 2003 · I think 440C is fine, as is 420HC by Buck etc. For bigger fixed blades I like the 420hc where I might need the extra toughness to chop a small limb and such. Nitro V goes in here too but not sure why they didn't put any numbers in the name. I would not waste my time re-profiling 154CM & S30V with the 600 grit lansky diamond rod. Can you tell me what the differences are between 420HC vs 440 C, and which one is better? The main difference between 420HC and 440 C stainless steel is that the first one is less hard. The only time you would want 420HC over S30V would be if you want a cheaper knife. S30V Steel Compared; 154cm vs. Jul 7, 2021 · X50CrMoV15 vs S30V Steel S30V steel is a powder metallurgy steel with better alloy composition and better performance than X50CrMoV15. Hardness directly influences edge retention and wear resistance. 14C28N VS VG10 When you compare S30V and 420HC, you will find that S30V is better in almost all ways. D2 is harder to sharpen and more prone to rust. Dec 17, 2010 · S30V is an excellent general purpose steel and has served many for along time now. 05% carbon. Both are similarly hard, but S30V is less brittle. CPM S30V vs VG10. 2. Is 420HC steel good for knives? 420HC is good knife steel in the low-end category. The choice between 154CM and S30V ultimately depends on your specific needs and preferences, as well as the intended use of the The qualities offered by the 154cm are close to the CPM S30V, they both offer the balance of hardness, toughness, wear resistance, and corrosion resistance, they the same of course, I find the S30V slightly better in Edge retention and hardness, and the 154CM is easier to sharpen compared to the S30V, but in the end, they ‘re both high-end Mar 31, 2005 · Is this a powder metallurgy vs. The biggest upside to S30V is that it is great for all tasks you could need a knife steel for. I've never seen it chip but if it does its probably a factory edge thing and will disappear after a sharpening or two. If you’re not someone who polishes and strops your edge I’d say cpms30v. 154CM is a custom steels with much higher carbon content, giving it a higher hardness ratings and dramatically higher edge retention. 6 days ago · 154CM and S30V are two popular knife steels known for their durability, edge retention, and resistance to corrosion. Aug 17, 2024 · We review the key differences in price and quality between the s30v vs 420hc steel - two exceptional knives. It beat S35VN in testing by 8. 420HC. 10Cr15CoMoV vs S35VN Nov 4, 2005 · I got a leatherman crater c33L pocket knife with 420HC blade its not hard to sharpen and use it as EDC cutting tools without any problem i dont know how it compared with buck 420HC but I prefer easier to sharpen blade since i can touch up in the field and 420HC is excellent in rust resistance the 154CM marketed to be 3 times better in holding its edge than 420HC dont know how Jan 20, 2004 · Since I've never used Buck's 420HC, I can't make any determinations, though the following is found on Buck's website. Edge Retention: S30V has superior edge retention compared to 154CM, thanks to its higher carbon and vanadium content. refer to the steel as S30V and others as CPM-S30V, but it’s the same thing. I think the biggest problem some people have with the newer steels is in re-profiling. BTW the 154CM vs CPM154 in the chart doesn't seem correct !!! Both have the same chemistry ,one is just a CPM version . For that reason, the S30V is a brilliant steel for your knife blade, and tends to offer the best qualities overall. Hardness significantly impacts a knife steel’s edge retention and wear resistance. 420HC is that the former is a premium steel knife ideal for people looking for excellent edge retention. Jul 8, 2023 · In comparison to 440C and 154CM, M390 steel provides better edge retention and corrosion resistance. Primarily because of the keen edge I can hone on the 154CM is more important to me than the purported toughness of the S30V. Aug 7, 2015 · 420HC. i would think that theres some performance gain on those newer steels Jun 5, 2024 · Made by US based Crucible, CPM S30V (often simply referred to as S30V) steel has excellent edge retention and resists rust effortlessly. Benchmades 154CM is much better than Leathermans based on the heat treat. This is only for a performance comparison between 420 and S30V as an example. Jul 13, 2023 · At A Glance. Likewise, Spydercos S30V is better than BMs S30v and S90V due to the better heat treat, and possibly blade geometry. S30V takes a finer edge then 154CM, and holds it about 30% longer. So I’m here to tackle the myth that all these new super steels being introduced every year are always better than the old reliables found in the vast majority of Aug 11, 2023 · S90V vs S30V: CPM S30V provides better toughness and wear resistance but lags behind S90V in edge retention and grindability. Read More: 154CM Knife Steel Review. Both steels also contain similar amounts of chromium, with 440C containing around 17% chromium and 154CM containing around 14% chromium. 154CM and s30V are boutique steels capable of higher hardness. Because it contains 0. However with the right treatment 420HC is definitely acceptable as a lower end blade steel. 154 cm has smaller carbides though and as another commenter stated it lends itself well to those who want the most refined edge possible. The comparison chart among s35vn vs d2 shows that s35vn is better than d2 steel. Jan 15, 2006 · How would one know what "most people do" Seems a wee bit pretentious to know or speak for "most people" without a disclaimer I'd rather hear from experience than from what one supposes "most people" do. S35VN is tougher than both (really closer to a 6). ive got a couple knives in 154 cm and find it a very nice knife steel. I notice a difference in sharpness between my 154CM blades and my S30V blades at the end of the day. This type of steel has a lower carbon content than S30V, making it easier to sharpen with traditional methods. Feb 2, 2023 · According to the Transverse Charpy C-notch test results there is no difference in the longitudinal toughness of both steel but S30V has much higher transverse toughness and this is the reason why S30V has excellent resistivity against chipping and breaking than the 154CM. 420HC does have decent resistance to corrosion but if you have a Jan 28, 2008 · Has anyone used Buck 12C27M enough to give a first impression/review of its performance. It will be much easier to sharpen 10Cr15CoMoV steel than it would be to sharpen S30V. 420HC S30V: which is more beneficial for you to use? Which one should you select? All these questions are cleared by comparing 420HC vs S30v neck to neck. 440C steel is another type of stainless steel known for its high chromium content, which provides good corrosion Jan 23, 2024 · S30V vs CPM 154 vs 154CM comparison table Hardness. Corrosion Resistance. So if Buck is nuts on in HT for S30V, the S30V is far superior in edge-holding to 420HC. After we went through the details about the S30V Steel, we finally arrived at our famous question, Is S30V good knife steel, I guess by now the answer is obvious “YES”, the steel offers high hardness, high wear resistance, high corrosion resistance, and a decent toughness, it’s considered a high-end Steel, and many users consider as a “SUPER STEEL”, And honestly I’m one of those Jan 28, 2008 · Well guys as we know Buck's intermediate lines are moving from 154cm to Sandvik 12C27M for the most part. Jul 30, 2019 · 440A (and similar grades including 425M, 420HC, and 6A) 154CM (ATS-34) Knife Steel. Sep 11, 2023 · S30V and 154CM are both high-quality stainless steels, but determining which is better depends on your specific needs and preferences. The ONLY advantage to the ELU is that 420HC is VERY rust resistant. Hardness is crucial in knife steel as it directly influences edge retention and wear resistance. 154CM is easier to sharpen than S30V, but S30V has better edge retention and is more wear-resistant. Then come the numbers and letters, such as 8cr, 9cr, 10cr, vg10, 12c27n, 154cm, 14c28n, bd1n, aus8, n690. Explore the Blade HQ Knife Steel Guide for insights on the latest knives, including customs, OTF knives, fixed blades, automatics, and more. Oct 2, 2004 · I've heard that Buck hardens S30V to R 59 and 420HC to R 58, so there isn't a heck of a lot of difference. Apr 15, 2024 · In contrast, 420HC is a martensitic stainless steel that can be hardened to around 55 HRC. S35VN vs. 420hc vs s30v – A Short Comparison. Ultimately, the choice between CPM M4 and S30V depends on the specific requirements and preferences of the user. Both still have a similar degree of toughness and corrosion resistance, while S30V is slightly superior in terms of edge retention. It offers excellent toughness, great corrosion resistance, and it is easy to sharpen. The best budget steel is hands down D2 because it's super tough and can hold an edge for way longer than that other stuff. com/listing/brickard-heritage-collectionGood gravy its bricky on thingsSubscribe and hit the bell! Hit like and all t Dec 30, 2022 · 440C VS 154CM Similarities: Both 440C and 154CM contain similar amounts of carbon, with 440C containing around 1. With higher end steels the manufacturer makes more of a difference when it comes to knife design, fit and finish, etc and less of a difference with blade quality (of course there is still some differences out there). This steel is sufficiently tough to withstand intense usage without chipping or breaking. My personal experience using 420HC (in a different knife) is that it benefits from frequent stropping, which I do not mind nearly as much as fixing chips. N690 is another stainless steel that offers high corrosion resistance and decent edge retention. Generally, the harder the steel, the less tough it is and vice versa. The VG10 is also a very balanced steel alloy, with lots of chromium for corrosion resistance and also vanadium to get more toughness. But in other ways, these 2 steels are very different. Conclusion After more than 20 years the 440C Steel kept its place as well-trusted steel for knives, today many new steels have made it to the knife industry, bringing their new technology leaving behind old steels like our Jul 7, 2018 · Leatherman S30V vs 420HC and 154CM - Edge Retention comp at 20º per side. 440C and 154CM steels are widely popular for their good overall performance, but M390 stands out for its superior performance. 420HC simply means it’s infused with a lot of carbon which makes the base 420 steel a bit harder and better overall than the regular 420 but unfortunately, it still suffers from similar drawbacks in toughness and wear resistance. With the short answer out of the way, we can take a closer look at each steel individually, when and why you would want one steel over the other, and how one steel is better than May 13, 2022 · Many steels can come quite close to the S30V and its qualities (such as VG10, 420HC, and S110V) but they typically have some component that just can’t equal it. Jul 8, 2023 · 154CM. Oct 7, 1998 · If you use a good sharpening system then 154CM is a dodle to sharpen, not noticibly harder to do than 420HC, it just takes a little longer because the steel is far more wear resistant. I intend to buy the boning knife as soon as it available but I'll have to depend on all ya'all till Apr 1, 2004 · But almost all 154CM/ATS-34, VG-10, S30V, M2, D2, etc are good quality. Corrosion-resistance vs. Mar 15, 2023 · While 154cm steel offers superior durability and edge retention, 420HC steel is sharp and easy to sharpen. I'm assuming its in between the two and I'm assuming its closer to 420HC than 154cm. Jul 12, 2023 · S30V vs CPM154 – Complete Comparison Hardness. Wear Resistance: S30V steel offers better wear resistance, which translates to a longer-lasting knife with less frequent sharpening required. The choice between the two depends on your specific needs and priorities. Toughness. S30V is a premium steel that will work well for pretty much any task you could need a knife for. Just observe the differences between s35vn vs d2 steel and make a choice. Simply put (IMO) S30V>440V=BG42>VG10>154CM=ATS34>ATS55=440C=AUS8>420HC>440A>AUS6>420SJ>stone. , but 440A and AUS6 just don't cut it. CPM M4 - the major difference is much better wear resistance at the cost of reduced toughness . Quality heat treatment raises 420HC’s Rockwell hardness to 56-58 HRC, though its standard rating is 55 HRC. But when carbides are bigger (e. S30V from a reputable company with good heat treat ie Spyderco/CRK will not chip from what I've seen. We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Both have similar edge thicknesses with the Benchmade being slightly thinner (~. 13C26 is being used as well (and its great) but the 12C27M seems to be the choice for the majority of the Avid/intermediate lines. Jan 24, 2022 · The only knife that has beaten this score, out of more than 100 knives that I have tested, was a Benchmade Pardue Spearpoint Auto in 154CM, which scored 98. 420HC stainless steel offers the same corrosion resistance as 9Cr18MoV stainless steel. Related Posts. 14C28N is essentially AEB-L (or perhaps more accurately Sandvik 13C26), but with improved Jul 11, 2007 · CPM-S30V is great steel, it has become the staple material used in several knives (Spyderco, Benchmade, ZT). S30V steel consists of greater edge retention and corrosion resistance than 420 HC. S30V has a Rockwell hardness (HRC) of 59-61, renowned for a good balance between edge retention and toughness. Usually TiN is matte, but TiAlN lokks as good as BoronCarbide. TYPES OF BLADE STEELS No matter how good the blade steel, there are always trade-offs. Thanks, Vassili. However, M390 still Aug 31, 2021 · 420HC vs 440C. Yes Buck has produced tons of knifes in 420hc to keep production cost down for the Walmart shoppers who wont pay more than $40 for a knife. Its chemistry has been rebalanced so that it forms some niobium carbides along with vanadium and chromium carbides. Jun 8, 2014 · I prefer 154CM. The addition of phosphorus and sulfur isn't that encouraging both decrease cutlery function in terms of toughness and wear resistance without giving anything in return. This method ensures that the carbides, the hard particles that keep the blade sharp, are distributed evenly throughout the steel, resulting in a more homogeneous product. S30V steel is a more rigid material and will retain its edge longer. This means that if you prefer to sharpen your knives, then 420HC may be the better choice Nov 22, 2007 · S30V has the stainless properties of 440C, so it's up there. Oct 14, 2009 · The increase in carbon is negligible and the more critical factor of vanadium that makes the CPM steels like S30V and S90V so good are absent in 12C27 vs 420HC. S30V demonstrates the highest attainable hardness out of these three stainless steels due to its higher alloy content and carbide volume. A Leatherman c301 knife has turned out to be a somewhat unlikely common EDC knife for me. It was designed in the US and is typically used for the high-end premium pocket knives and expensive kitchen cutlery. 154CM. have no experience with m390 or elmax, these are much newer steels than 154 variants. Because of its high cost, S30V is used to make premium kitchen knives, high-end pocket knives, scout knives, and custom knives. Feb 25, 2023 · The edge-holding capability of CPM S30V steel is especially noteworthy; pocket knives made with this steel are sure to stay sharp for a long time. Also, not all steels of the same kind are created equal. I also find that 154CM has very good stain resistance. Before S30V came out in 2001, most of the high-performance steels used for knives were originally designed for something else, and borrowed by knifemakers for use in cutlery. Let’s compare 14c28n steel with other steels, and for this, I use four criteria; Edge Retention, Corrosion resistance, Ease of Sharpness, and Toughness and on a scale of 1-10 (10 being the highest) let’s see the performance of each steel. I have never used CPM154, but I greatly prefer 154CM to 420HC because of better edge retention. Most production knives are more than thick enough at the edge to accommodate a regrind to significantly improve performance, and it’s a lot cheaper than buying a new knife a lot of the time. S30V vs. There are some other stainless steels that I haven't used, but this Apr 17, 2018 · I can’t explain why. As stated earlier we will be discussing different features of each. S30V Knife Steel. 2% carbon and 154CM containing around 1. All the same, 420HC is considered a soft alloy in comparison to superior 400 series grades and other more modern knife blade steel. Basically… If money isn’t an obstacle for you, go with the S30V. It does not excel in all areas but it does hold its own. Jun 15, 2023 · 420 stainless steel is softer than S30V steel, meaning it is easier to sharpen but will not hold its edge as well. The higher hardness of CPM S35VN compared to other steels like 420HC and 154CM is achieved through the formation of vanadium and niobium carbides, which are more effective at providing wear resistance than standard chromium carbides. S45VN is more corrosion resistant than both (really a 7). Many people say that their S30V production blades cut poorly as OOTB, and I can confirm, as far as my experience is concerned. 4% Vanadium in S30V is helpful to add wear resistivity and hardening Sep 26, 2021 · S30v Steel. Feb 22, 2021 · 154CM is a very high carbon stainless steel with the addition of Molybdenum. May 8, 2005 · Moving from Cold Steel's AUS-8A to Benchmade's 154CM, I saw about double the edge-retention in plain-edged blades (didn't measure edge retention in serrated blades). S30V, while pricier, offers better performance overall. lgvcpme sprvbp lkokyu rigl zzsm hkxfjju psfzd jykm leq cgim